Chapter XLI
The Proposal To Complete The Canal By Contractors' Groups


While the work on the isthmus by the first French company had excited some interest on the part of the American engineers at its inception, comparatively few found employment thereon, and during the construction and for the decade following the appointment of the receiver for the company, the American engineer or contractor rarely heard of and paid small heed to the undertakings on the isthmus.

Busied with plans and undertakings for all kinds of construction work in the development of our own internal waterways, railways, hydro-electric properties, sanitation, and buildings, there was work at home for all the talent of engineers and contractors in the beginning of one of the greatest eras of construction work ever inaugurated in America.  And it is therefore not surprising that the tremendous impetus to patriotism aroused by the Spanish War should not have to wait to find a most ready expression in the individuals who for one cause or another had been denied the privilege of fighting for the flag in Cuba or Manila, while busied in the great undertakings at home.  Accordingly, when the first isthmian commission was appointed to consider the whole question of isthmian transit by navigation the engineering and contracting fraternity of the United States patiently waited to be called into service for the greatest single undertaking of all ages in the line of their chosen work.

The isthmian canal was to become an accomplished fact, a world work was to be done by Americans with American brains, brawn and money, for Americans and for all the nations of the earth for all time.  And it was no uncommon interest which was manifested in the query:  Would it be done by the administration and those trained in government service, and be carried on as an army undertaking; or would those supposedly most skilled by experience in each particular department of this most complex and exceptionally great work be called from among the ranks of the nation's best civilians, who were trained executives in construction work and who could offer the immediate benefit of efficient existing organizations to aid the country in its great undertaking?

The Spanish War had done much more than put upon a secure footing the peace and happiness of a few neighboring Latin Americans and distant islanders.  It had suddenly made the undertaking of the construction of the Panama Canal by Americans a national necessity, and the war's experience had uncovered a relief from one of the chief causes of previous failure on the isthmus.  The causes of malaria and yellow fever were no longer a mystery to science, and the medical profession was to play a prominent part in the construction in the great work.

Men could now live and think and work on the isthmus through wet and dry months. The medical profession had already blazed the trail for successful accomplishment by the engineer and constructor, and the bête noir of the French, the Chagres River, vanished like its own rising miasma at noontide.  The problem for the engineer and constructor was simply one of men enough, plant enough, time enough, and money enough, and the canal would be an accomplished fact at a cost which our government could well afford to pay.

Into the conferences of the Isthmian Canal Commission and the Board of Consulting Engineers, many of the leading engineers and contractors of the country were called from time to time, and after nearly three years of study, survey, and actual construction by the government, the waiting American contract world was rewarded for its interest in the matter by the suggestion that the government might soon consider the advisability of contracting the work of completing the canal by associating with the work of the commission the best trained talent of the world in each department of the undertaking; the plan contemplating a competition for the work between groups of contractors, each group composed of contractors who had achieved notable success in some of the departments of construction involved in the undertaking and whose combined experience covered the whole task, and whose reputations, like that of Caesar's wife, must be above suspicion, and whose combined capital would be sufficient at all times to carry out their undertakings with the government.

For the formation of one such group of contractors, MacArthur Brothers Company were early invited, many months prior to any public discussion of the matter and before any definite qualifications and requirements expected from possible bidders had been formulated by the commission.

Finally the question of contracting the completion of the work was discussed by the chairman of the Isthmian Canal Commission in a communication addressed to the Secretary of War, dated August 29, 1906.  A copy of the communication was made public and submitted to prospective bidders, as indicating to them some of the reasons why the work was to be let to contractors, and the general qualifications and requirements which would be exacted by the government.

The widespread interest manifested in the work on the canal, which so far had been conducted under the immediate direction of the civilian chief engineers, one of whom had inaugurated the great work in its most trying period and stayed with it but little over a year, and who successor was at this time barely entering upon his second year of incumbency, was now most naturally intensified in the public mind.   When the announcement was made that President Roosevelt was seriously considering the placing of the completion of the canal under contract, the plan was interpreted by many to mean an admission of defeat by the government to its own organization, and dire results were predicted for the fortunes of any group of contractors who would enter into any partnership or dual performance with the government in this stupendous and risky undertaking.  The enemies of the canal at home and abroad wisely shook their heads and rushed into print for a period.

Under the fire of such public discussion it was no easy task to enlist the interest of contractors in the groups desired by the government.   Contractors of national reputation, achievement, and financial responsibility had to be induced by much argument, suggestion, and effort to join such a combination.   The multiplied divisions of the work extended over a long series of years, and the necessary division of profits did not appeal to large contracting concerns, all of whom were profitably employing their capital and organization at home.  Millions of capital and credit was to be interested in the proposed groups, for a long time, under so many conditions of risk, attendant with the personal danger to health in the tropics, that contractors and capital became shy of the undertaking after their first enthusiasm had subsided.  The first drafts of invitations to bidders and proposed forms of contracts were many times modified and finally withdrawn, after much discussion between the President of the United States, the members of his cabinet, the chairman of the commission, and the intending bidders.

The frankness and evident fairness of these discussion, in an effort to harmonize all views and obtain the best results for the government, with a fair compensation for the contractor with the minimum of risk, characterized all the discussions at which the writer had the honor to be present.   But finally in pursuance of the general plan, invitations were publicly issued to bidders throughout the country under date of October 9, 1906, calling for the reception of bids January 12, 1907.

After many weeks of fruitless negotiation between groups of contractors, and within a very few days of the time set for receiving bids, it became evident that few, if any, groups of contractors through the country could be formed, or bankers enlisted into the groups for the undertakings proposed by the government.  Accordingly the specifications and financial requirements were at the last moment very materially modified, cutting down the bond to be given by the contractors from $3,000,000 to $2,000,000, and the available cash capital required down to $5,000,000, which was always to be kept intact in the treasury of the contracting group.

Several hundred copies of the invitation to bidders and forms of contract were given out and received by and seriously considered by the contractors of the country.  And the widest publicity was likewise given through the popular and technical journals.

Bids from several competent groups were expected by the commission, as several tentative groups were known to have been formed for the purpose of bidding.

When it came, however, to the reception of the bids, while four bids only were presented, only one of them had complied with the terms and vital requirements of the invitations.  That was the bid of the MacArthur-Gillespie Commune, a group organized for the purpose of completing the construction of the canal pursuant to the invitation of the government, and composed of four of the most successful contracting concerns in the country.  Each of the four concerns composing the group was recognized as having had a longer, wider and more successful experience in the field of contracting than any of the other bidders; and all had a larger experience in all the important branches of the work called to be done on the canal, and with a larger organization of trained and experienced men to draw from than all the other bidders combined.

For the successful, economical, and certain execution of the great work it was thought that the government had received in the bid of the MacArthur-Gillespie group the strength of the strongest and the skill of the most experienced contractors in the country.

Th proposed contract for which the bidders tendered was based upon theory of paying the contracting group the cost of the work which they undertook to perform plus a percentage for the risks assumed and profits expected by the group.  The performance of the work, however, was to be a dual one by the commission and the contractor on a hitherto untried basis in the history of government contracts.

Large risks not incident to other government contracts were to be assumed by the contractor.  It was difficult to determine what possibilities of risk might arise, and if they did arise by whom were they to be assumed.   Some of the most important functions upon which the success or failure of the contractor hinged were specially reserved and retained in the control of the commission.

The method of estimating the cost and time for the construction of the canal and the work which the contractor assumed was to be determined by an engineering committee of five members, two to be nominated by the contractors, and three by the commission, of which three one should be the chief engineer of the commission.  This engineering committee was to be nominate after the contract should be executed and after the contractor had assumed all obligations, backed with its bond and cash resources.  To some contractors the whole principle of the contracting group idea reduced the actual doers of the work to mere employees of the government, whose pay would become most uncertain and whose capital and time would be jeopardized.  It is not surprising, therefore, that only four bids should be received and that, considering figures only, they should have varied in expected compensation to the contractor, being in numerical order as follows:  6.75 percent, 7.17 percent, 12.5 percent, and 28 percent.  The wide range in the tenders was obviously the measure of the varying estimates of hazard existing in the judgment of the bidders.

To the public mind it appeared remarkable that a bid made upon a percentage basis should afford opportunity for such a range of risk, but an intelligent examination of the contract provisions and conditions under which the contractor was to receive his final compensation will, in the light of our knowledge today, now that the canal is completed, and its cost ascertained, force the conclusion that had either one of the two lowest bids been accepted and the contract undertaken, the unfortunate group would have long since lost all its original $5,000,000 capital and several millions more, had it been able to progress with the work up to its nearly completed stage, or the government would have had a forfeited contract on its hands.

The bid of the MacArthur-Gillespie Company of 12.50 percent, so strongly urged for acceptance upon the government at the time, would have resulted in dividends of patriotism to be distributed among its group.

There were doubtless contractors who would have undertaken the great work for a less percentage even than the so-called lowest bidder submitted, with the hope of snatching the first fruits therefrom and leaving the government in the lurch when the day of trial came.  And well might the group of men who had submitted the only tender which complied with the terms and requirements of the invitations and specifications object to their efforts being laid aside, while serious consideration was being given to an informal tender.  However, the right to consider an informal tender was reserved to the commission in the "General Instructions to Bidders," and thus by inference the warning to intending bidders against informality in their bids was nullified and the door left open for the commission to make the best trade it could for the government.  This is the commission sought to do with the lowest informal bidder, who upon his own suggestion was given time to qualify in the necessary financial and other requirements of the proposal, but not until after many formal protests had been made by able counsel in the interests of the MacArthur-Gillespie bid against such a proceeding, and oral arguments and printed briefs had been considered thoughtfully and fairly by the President and the commission in support of the contention for the right to the award, if any were to be made by the government, to the MacArthur-Gillespie Company, and not until after the writer on behalf of that company had in a personal interview with the President assured him of the hearty acquiescence by the group be represented in any procedure which would secure for the government the completion of the canal project on the wisest and most favorable terms to the country.

The rejection of all bids some days later, and the placing of the great enterprise again into the hands of the army engineers for completion by the administration of the President through the commission, must now, after the years of successful accomplishment, meet with the unqualified approval of the American people.

It is far from one of the fundamental duties of good government that the action of its representatives should pursue the individual to his ruin.  The suggestion to put this great national work under contract invited the possibility of such an outcome, and would have deprived the nation's faithful servants, the army, of participation in the glories of the actual accomplishment of the greatest single peaceful enterprise ever undertaken by any government.

The construction of the canal is now an accomplished fact, and well may the American engineers in civil life and contractors doff their hats to Col. George W. Goethals of the Army Corps and his group of trained constructors.   They have proven themselves the silent, informal, and successful bidders for the contract which the President and commission might have overlooked had they not been looking for the best trade for the government with contractors.