Colonel Goethals' Address At Annual
Banquet of the Society of the Chagres
Tivoli Hotel, March 6, 1915
Fellow Members of the Chagres Society:
Mr. May, the newly-elected President of the Chagres Society, said that there was but one
speech to made tonight at the banquet, and that the Committee requested that I make it.
I am not much on speaking except in the office, but I asked Mr. May if he would
prepare the speech. He promised to do it. I saw Mr. Baxter a few days after
and told him I expected to make a speech and asked him to assist in its preparation.
Mr. Baxter looked wooden. Mr. McIlvaine urged me to come tonight and make a
few remarks, and I told him I would, provided a speech were prepared for me.
"Oh!" he said, "that would be quite easy." I have not seen
anything of Mr. Baxter from that time until I met him here tonight. McIlvaine said
this morning he thought I was joking. Mr. May came in with a few platitudes
and though I could add to them and that would make a sufficient speech. Mr. May
used to be useful; but he has joined the judiciary. His motto now is maņana.
Eight years ago today I sailed from New York to assume charge of this work. On the
17th of March, eight years ago, a smoker was given at Corozal to which I was invited.
I attended. The cheering was all in favor of Mr. Stevens. Any reference
made to his successor was met with cold silence. The toastmaster, whom I see here
tonight, made some remarks about the Army, suggesting to a party of Congressmen who were
present, that if in going around the work they should see the men suddenly drop their
tools, assume the attitude of a solider, and make a military salute, they should not
consider the men "loco," but simply preparing for the new administration which
was to assume charge. (Addressing Mr. Kyte.) You remember that, Mr. Kyte?
Those remarks coupled with other insinuations and slurs upon the Army rather
irritated and angered me, and I made my maiden speech. At that time I told you men,
as you may remember if you were present on that occasion, that I would look after your
interests, as they would be my own; and every man would have the right of audience -- and
that promise I have kept. (A voice: "You bet you have.")
I have attended this dinner tonight not because I enjoy banquets, but because it is
probably the last one I will have opportunity to attend, for after eight years of
responsibility I feel that I am entitled to some rest, so I have asked to be relieved and
hope that I may be some time during the coming year in order that a younger man whose
energy is unimpaired may take up the work and carry it forward.
In the spring of 1907, if you men remember, there were a number of labor questions being
agitated, and one of the first things I was called upon to do was to settle the wage
schedule between the Commission and the locomotive engineers, the conductors, and the
steam-shovel crews. Mr. Stevens had declined to deal with the men when they took the
matter over his head and carried it to the President. Mr. Taft was soon to come to
the Isthmus to discuss the question with the labor committees and to decide what should be
done in the matter. There are, undoubtedly, some of you here who attended the
hearing that the Secretary of War, Mr. Taft, gave in the Panama Railroad office at Colon.
Mr. Stevens and Mr. Bierd had recommended that the pay of the locomotive engineers
be placed on a parity with the pay of the steam-shovel engineers, as in the States
steam-shovel engineers usually got less than locomotive engineers. Mr. Taft feared
that if the steam-shovel men received no increase that there might be labor trouble.
He was not in favor of increasing their pay to $300 per month, which they demanded,
but thought something should be done for them. He suggested increase to length of
service and I then recommended to him that longevity be granted, and that length of
service should govern for all classes of service on the Isthmus. (Great applause.)
He could not give longevity to the steam-shovel engineers without giving it to the
locomotive engineers and maintain the parity which Mr. Stevens claimed should be
maintained and he ought not to give it to the steam-shovel engineers and the locomotive
engineers without giving it to men in other classes of employment. (Applause) He was
to give his decision, if you remember, from Cuba; when he reached Cuba he decided to
postpone the matter until he reached Washington and conferred with Mr. Roosevelt, then the
President; after his return to Washington I received a cablegram asking whether the
longevity should be given at the end of one year's service or at the end of a greater
length of time. I suggested 5 per cent at the end of two years' service with an
increase for each succeeding year. The upshot of the matter was than an increase was
given to transportation crews, and longevity was to be granted to the steam-shovel crews,
the transportation crews, and the mechanical trades at the rate of 5 per cent increase for
the first year's service and an increase of 3 per cent for each succeeding year's service.
That information was received by me on a Sunday afternoon by cablegram. I
gave the word out the next day, and you know the result. The locomotive engineers
with an increase to $210 per month when qualified to operate on the main line were well
pleased, but the steam-shovel engineers considered that they had not received proper
recognition and determined to withdraw their services from the Canal. A few days
subsequently I received by mail a copy of the President's decision, which gave 3 per cent
increase for the first year's service and 3 per cent for each succeeding year. I had
already announced 5 per cent for the first year. I determined I would not break
faith with the men, and I adhered to the 5 per cent, subsequently explaining the situation
to the President and securing his approval of my action.
If you remember, the Appropriations Committee of the House first visited the Isthmus in
November of 1907. Among the other things they criticised was the longevity pay.
In the meantime the pressure for an extension of longevity had become great, for
other men who were doing equally valuable service and who were receiving no recognition
for length of service other than their straight pay, they they should also granted the
longevity increase. (Applause.) When I visited Washington in 1907 I saw the
Secretary of War and explained the situation to him; I showed him that the men were not
being justly treated who had not received increase for longevity as I had in the first
instance recommended. However, the congressional criticism had been so strong he
stated he would not grant the increase unless Congress specifically authorized it for
classes of employees other than those already included. In the spring of 1909 the
pressure became more than I could withstand. I took it up with the Congressional
Committee and told them longevity should be given to everybody or to nobody. The
upshot of it was that Mr. Tawney told me that the Committee had decided to withdraw
longevity for everybody. I asked him if he considered that this would mean a
reduction in the pay of the men already receiving it. He said he had not -- that the
bill had not been drafted, but that they would take it up with me when they came to frame
up the bill. I went to President Roosevelt and explained the situation to him, and
he drafted a letter to Speaker Cannon asking that the prohibition against longevity be
withdrawn, and that longevity be extended to everybody, applying to all classes equally.
I took that letter to Speaker Cannon and had quite a session with him. He was
opposed to it; opposed to it not because he did not think the men should have longevity
but because it created an undesirable precedent, and efforts were being made for similar
privileges in the Government service in the United States. He did not believe it
should be granted, and on that account a clause was inserted in the Sundry Civil Bill
enacted in 1909, which limited longevity to that which had been acquired up to that time.
Attempts have been made since then for longevity, and my position always has been
and always will be that longevity should be given to all or to none. (Great
applause.)
When the Secretary of War, Mr. Garrison, visited the Isthmus a couple of years ago
a committee secured from him a letter to the effect that there seemed to be some equity in
the claim that longevity should be paid to those whose conditions of employment
specifically specified that they would get longevity. A year ago I went to
Washington. The order had already issued in connection with the reorganization.
I found the unions who were represented in Washington determined, as far as
possible, to put through longevity for those whose conditions of employment called for
longevity, making use of the Secretary of War's letter. That would have affected a
comparatively small number of employees, and would not have made it applicable to those
who had not enjoyed its privileges previously. When the Panama Canal Act was first
brought to the attention of employees I had assured the men that as far as it lay in my
power I would continue the construction wage scale until the completion of the
construction work. I discussed the matter with President Taft when he was here in
1912, and he said he would see that no objection was made to it if I took the
responsibility. When I discussed the question with the Secretary of War in 1913, he
stated that a strict compliance with the law would not permit a continuance of the wage
scale as it then existed, and, if you recall, a year ago we issued information stating
what the wage scale would be under the operation and maintenance of the Canal. I
then told the committees of the labor organizations who came to interview me that if I
could not get the construction wage scale continued during the construction period, I
would do my best to stave off the rent proposition until the construction work was
completed, or at least for one year. A year ago when in Washington I took up with
the leaders of the House the question of longevity, I called attention to the letter the
Secretary of War had given on the subject to some of the labor unions on the Isthmus, and
explained to them that the attitude I had always taken and still held was that longevity
should be given to all or to none. It was absolutely impossible to secure
legislation giving longevity to all. It was extremely doubtful if longevity could be
secured for the few who had previously enjoyed its privileges, and whose contract of
employment embodied the suggestion. I met with the representatives of the labor
unions in the States and explained the situation to them; I proposed to them that we cut
out longevity since there was no hope of getting it for all; stated that I would do my
best to defeat longevity for the few; and suggested that they join with me in
maintaining the construction wage scale until the end of the construction period.
The labor leaders there did not feel that they could take the necessary action without
consulting with the men on the Isthmus. Time did not permit of this, as the Urgent
Deficiency Bill had passed the House and was then in the hands of the Senate Committee; I
had made arrangements with the Senate Committee for a hearing on the proposition, and the
labor leaders agreed the following morning before I went to the Committee that they would
not attempt to interfere with any legislation I might suggest looking toward the retention
of the existing wage scale. I had had a conference with the Appropriations Committee
of the House and explained to them the situation -- that I had promised the men in 1912
that I would do what I could to maintain the construction wage scale until the completion
of the Canal, and they stated if I could convince the Senate Committee and get a clause
introduced confirming it, they would interpose no objection. The result you already
know. Longevity was knocked out but the wage scale was maintained, and this
benefited a greater number of people than the reestablishment of longevity applying to the
special classes as before would have done. That is the situation on longevity.
Another point that has agitated everybody here tonight is the rent question.
When the members of the Committee of Congress in 1907 visited the Isthmus they had very
much to say not only on the liberal wage scale, but also on the privileges accorded to
employees. If you remember, they visited every type house on the isthmus, including
mine. It was at that time that a Member of Congress suggested that they go upstairs
in my house in order that they might see how we lived. This rather angered me;
I did not think it any of their business. He remarked that as I got such a house
with a salary of $15,000 a year, he presumed that if he were on the Isthmus, his salary
being $7,500, he would get a house of proportionate size. I told him that he was
mistaken; that if he were on the Isthmus he would not get anything near $7,500 a year.
The laugh was on him. We had visited Empire and Cascadas and were returning
to Culebra to hold hearings in the old Administration Building. If you remember, in
those days the electric current was turned on at 11 o'clock to operate the fans in the
hotels and as we drove up the road at Culebra every porch light at Culebra was burning.
To the members of the committee this was a waste of electric current -- a useless
expenditure of Government funds -- we were getting too many privileges, and did not
deserve what we got; and the rent business started in 1907 when the committee visited the
Isthmus. As the result of that visit the money needed for constructing quarters was
limited to the needs at that time and effective January 1, 1908, the conditions of
employment were changed by which married quarters were not to be provided, though given if
available. From this resulted lists 1 and 2 for quarters. The rent question
has been agitated by every committee that has visited the Isthmus since that date.
In 1912 when we decided to move the headquarters to the Pacific end, money was needed for
new quarters and for the transfer of old. At that time we hoped to have money enough
to build, or rebuild, quarters for practically everybody. The slides and other
contingencies prevented. I asked for an appropriation of $2,000,000 and it was given
with the understanding that rent would be charged as soon as the houses were
completed. I staved this off with the suggestion that rent be charged only when the
reorganization became effective. Every committee that has been down here since 1907
has strongly objected to the privileges. I have never objected to labor committees
interviewing committees of Congress when here. If they secured by Congressional
legislation any additional privileges, and the cost of the Canal was increased thereby,
the responsibility was theirs and not mine. I never attended any of these hearings,
because I desired the men to have full liberty to make their talks to the committees
without any interference by officials. This November a committee visited Congress
and put up their complaints. Their complaints covered everything; the congressional
party were impressed by the fact that there was not one good thing on the Isthmus for
which anybody would care to remain, and the rent proposition became more intense, finally
foreing the matter to a head. The question finally resolved itself down to getting
the cheapest rents that were possible for employees. Members of the Congressional
Committee thought that the apartments of the new four-family type should rent at $30 per
month, and the others in proportion. You know how the scale of rents in determined
in the States -- The cost of the property, the cost of repairs, the cost for schools, the
cost for prisons, the cost for sewers, water, streets, roads -- all of these and other
expenses are taken into consideration in one way or another, but none of that is taxed to
the employees here, and we have made the scale practically on the basis of the cost of
repairs, throwing in the furniture. The matter could not be staved off any longer;
it had to be accepted, and it had to be accepted on the best terms that could be secured
for the employees. So much for the rents.
A committee has just gone to Washington to see if they can get the order revoked.
As I told them when I saw them last Sunday morning, I wished them Godspeed, for if
it helps them it helps me and helps us all. Whether they will or not remains to be
seen. Congress is not is session, and the President may be induced to view the
matter from a different standpoint. It is claimed by some that rent is an effort to
reduce wages. The rent is one thing and the wage scale is another. When the
new organization went into effect a year ago, I knew that the time was coming when rents
would have to be charged -- when the Congressional Committee would not stand for an
appropriation necessary for repairs, furnishing, and everything else. The conditions
of employment prescribes that rents will be charged under such rules and regulations as
the President may prescribe. We succeeded in putting it off for nearly a year.
Employees were notified that if they cared to continue in the service, they would
do so under the new conditions of employment, and that unless they resigned before April
1, 1914, they would be considered as agreeing to the conditions of employment. Those
now employed accepted the rent provision. I received today the minutes of the mass
meeting that was held at the Casino when the committee was selected to discuss this rent
question, and I find in it a statement by Father McDonald that when an attempt is made to
reduce the wage it is always the men at the bottom who suffer. I desire to say that
that statement so far as the Canal is concerned, is not true. The wage scale on the
Isthmus has always been a difficult one to handle; there has always been inequality;
clerks have not gotten the same proportionate pay as locomotive engineers and some other
men in the mechanical trades, nor have draftsmen; so when the Panama Canal Act was framed
I advocated an increase over that received in the States applicable to all classes, and I
advocated a certain percentage of increase. The great difficulty with the government
service is that Congress usually appropriates for certain positions and specifies the pay
of the several positions, from which there is no escape. An effort has been made
from time to time to apply this system to our appropriations, but thus far it has not been
done. As a result the Government employee in the States gets the same wage from year
to year; there is not,as there is in civil life, an increase commensurate with greater
efficiency and enlarged duties. Nor does it keep pace with prevailing scales in
outside establishments. I was anxious to have fixed for the Canal service a wage
scale higher than that paid in the States, and at the same time one that could be adjusted
to the increases when they occur; we succeeded so well that the bill provides for a 25 per
cent increase. At the time the bill was up I stated that the salaries of the higher
positions were too high and advocated a reduction. The salary of the Governor was
fixed at $10,000, so when I accepted the place a year ago I accepted a reduction of about
33 1-3 per cent. When a year ago I advocated the retention of the construction wage
scale, the labor organization representatives asked me afterward if they could not work
for a restoration of my pay. I told them no -- that my pay made but little
difference -- that it was the pay of the men on the Isthmus with which I was most
concerned. My pay today is one-third less than it was a year and a half ago, though
we are still engaged in construction work and the responsibility has not decreased.
the suggestion came up that most of the Governors of the States are furnished houses free
of rent. I said I stand with the men; if they pay rent, I will. Father
McDonald's statement is not true as illustrated by the Panama Canal.
There is one other subject I desire to touch upon -- a subject that I understand
has been under discussion on the Isthmus for the past three or four days -- and that is,
the promotion given to the service people; officers of the Army, Navy, and Marine Hospital
Corps. Mr. Taft, in his passage of 1912, recommended that I be promoted to the
position of Major-General in the Army. (Great applause.) Two friends of mine
in Congress, one in the Senate and one in the House, immediately introduced bills for that
purpose. I wrote and told them service men should have no promotion, unless
promotions could be given to all alike. that attitude I have consistently
maintained. It is a source of regret to me that the bill ever passed.
Civilians built the Canal; not the Army; when the Army people leave here they are retired
and looked after the Government, whereas the civilian must get out and hustle to make a
living for the rest of his days; and I have always opposed it. So far as longevity
is concerned, gentlemen, I am ready to help you in every move you make, as I have always
been ready to help in any move for the men on the Isthmus, but I will not help unless the
move includes everybody and all classes.
For sometime we have been endeavoring to secure a civil service status for our
employees and after conference with the Civil Service Commission in January last, an
Executive Order was issued giving to employees of the Canal who served satisfactorily for
two years prior to January 1, 1915, eligibility of transfer to similar service in the
United States without examination. this has already helped some former employees to
secure employment and will probably assist others.
There is only one thing more I want to say. We are gathered here tonight, not
in the hope of something yet to be accomplished, but of actual accomplishment -- the two
oceans have been united. The slides hinder and prevent navigation for a few days,
but in time they will be removed. The construction of the Canal means but little in
comparison with its coming usefulness to the world and what it will bring about. Its
completion is due to the brain and brawn of the men who are gathered here -- men who have
served loyally and well, and no commander in the world ever had a more faithful force than
that which has worked with me in building the Panama Canal. (Prolonged applause.)
CZBrats
February 5, 2000
Click Back Button To Return To Previous Page